A Tale of Two Cities, and a Bridge

CREDIT: INTERNATIONAL CENTRE OF PHOTOGRAPHY
CREDIT: INTERNATIONAL CENTRE OF PHOTOGRAPHY

Despite its name, the Brooklyn Bridge has always seemed to belong more to Manhattan than to Brooklyn. Weegee’s 1940 photo of lighting bolt apparently striking the then Bank of Manhattan Trust Building says as much. By foregrounding the photo with the Brooklyn Bridge leading to the skyscrapers of Manhattan — and with Brooklyn nowhere in sight — Weegee captured a popular view of the bridge that follows, and has been followed, by many who have photographed it. The typical act of photographing the Brooklyn Bridge probably goes something like this: cross over to the Brooklyn end of the bridge, turn around, and point your camera towards Lower Manhattan. Unlike the mess of low-rise buildings and wharves of Brooklyn, the gleaming skyscrapers across the East River form the prefect backdrop to accompany the engineering marvel.

But the Brooklyn Bridge was not always portrayed as the umbilical cord of Manhattan. When the bridge first opened on 24th May, 1883, many newspapers and magazines ran a color painting depicting the grand display of fireworks above it through the “view from New York, looking towards Brooklyn.” Another illustration from the same period also depicted the bridge from this perspective, although it is actually difficult to tell the two cities apart. Then, Manhattan had not yet been planted with the skyline of skyscrapers that would one day distinguish it from Brooklyn. In fact, when the bridge was built, Brooklyn was an independent city and it wasn’t until close to two decades later in 1898 that it was consolidated with the other boroughs to form the modern New York City that we know today.  

brooklynbridgefireworks1883

Birds-Eye-View-of-Brooklyn-Bridge-1883

When it first opened, the Brooklyn Bridge was the world’s first steel-wire suspension bridge and boasted the longest span in the world, stretching some 1,600 feet from tower to tower. Such an engineering feat foretold the coming of new construction techniques that would revolutionize buildings in the early 20th century, leading to the birth and proliferation of skyscrapers in Manhattan, the world’s financial capital. It was such a city that Weegee — then known as Arthur Felling — arrived at in 1909 when he traveled from Austria to join his father here. By then, the tale of two cities between the Brooklyn Bridge was already set in motion. Living for close to six decades in New York, Weegee saw the bridge struggle to hold on to Manhattan and Brooklyn as a growing gap in development emerged. Even his photos showed that: most of it were shot in Manhattan, where life in New York City happened. On the other hand, Brooklyn, in the words of one observer, was just the “bedroom” for the thousands who worked in Manhattan.  

As capital and construction flowed towards Manhattan, so did the Brooklyn Bridge. It seemed Brooklyn was no longer worthy to frame the bridge named after it. Photo after photo from the 1960s onwards depict it against the skyline of Manhattan, which together formed a picture perfect postcard of New York City’s engineering and financial might combined. Some five years after Weegee passed away in 1968, this image was cemented in the minds of the people. Then, a new architectural and engineering marvel had arrived in Manhattan: the World Trade Center, which was the tallest buildings in the world when it completed in 1973. These twin buildings, each standing at 1,368 feet, mirrored Brooklyn Bridge’s two towers — except both were in Manhattan. As the World Trade Center became recognized as quintessentially New York over the years, so did this view of the Brooklyn Bridge foregrounding it. In the years after the 9-11 tragedy, the bridge seemed to lose some of its distinction without the missing World Trade Center towers. Something just seemed missing in photos, although the upcoming One World Trade Center should restore Manhattan’s allure over the Brooklyn Bridge.

1974

Manhattan’s monopoly over the gaze of the Brooklyn Bridge may not be for much longer though. With gentrification and its growing reputation as a hip neighborhood to live, work and play, it is getting tougher to overlook Brooklyn. The borough has seen a few skyscrapers spring up too, although nothing particularly notable in terms of architecture yet. But why should it follow in the footsteps of Manhattan and fall into some race for the skies? The conversion of Brooklyn’s former piers and wharves into parks and other kind of public spaces create a different kind of background and frame for the Brooklyn Bridge, which could be just as interesting when viewed across the river. 

Like how the Brooklyn Bridge’s suspension system is kept together by tension, the disparity between Manhattan and Brooklyn is what keeps people returning to photograph this New York City icon. We each pick our sides and angles to get a picture of what we think the city looks like through our eyes.

Manhattan or Brooklyn, which side are you on?

———–
Written for Adam Levy’s Researching Design class at D-Crit.

Arranging a Room Full of Possibilities

For years, I did not sleep on a bed. While most people fuss about making their bed sheets and buying the right mattress, I’ve never had to think of these when I slept on a tatami mat.

Such rice straw mattresses are more commonly used as floors in Japanese-style homes. I lived in a public housing apartment in Singapore with only a single mattress big enough for me to lie on. It could be folded into a compact accordion in seconds, and laying the mattress to start and end the day became a ritual. After arising from slumber every morning, I would flip the bed up on its side, and fold it to keep at one corner of my room until it was time to sleep again.

The impermanence of where I slept turned my bedroom into a space of possibilities. Some days, I woke up to the sight of my neighborhood. And on other nights, I turned in under the watchful eyes of the world map and graphic posters plastered on the wall perpendicular to the windows. With the bed tucked into a corner whenever I was awake, the room became my office, a sanctuary to read, a spot for meals, and a cocoon for contemplation.

This flexibility mirrors the regular shifts in a room where I assembled and formed my identity for over two decades. My family and I moved into this two-story apartment on the sixth floor when I was five years old. I used to share one of the three bedrooms with my grandmother until she passed away after I turned twelve. With the room to myself, it became a canvas for the teenage me to fashion who I wanted to be.

Then, I did not have a tatami mattress yet. But I was already without a bed, a nomad in my room. The adults had decided it would be more spacious if my grandmother and I slept on mattresses without bed frames so they could be kept aside in the day. Rather than fill the void with the passing of my grandmother, I kept this arrangement and cherished the newfound space.

tatamimattress

Arranging your room is an act of constructing self in material form. One of the first things I moved in was a shelving system from IKEA. This became an early framework to house my life. While the room’s in-built cabinets hid my clothes along one wall, perpendicular to it were the open shelves that displayed my youth: books by Roald Dahl, science fiction novels like Robotech, and space-aged LEGO toys.

As I grew up, so did the contents of the shelves. What once took up half a wall next to my door eventually stretched the full length up to my window. Throughout the years, I periodically re-arranged the shelves and its contents to make room for new interests in my life. First came the computer magazine, MacAddict, and books on Steve Jobs and his company, Apple. Then I started buying CDs: Matchbox Twenty, Fastball and Oasis. In the mix also came political manifestos and guides, as Bertrand Russell, Karl Marx and Michel Foucault moved in. They became neighbors to a burgeoning book collection on Singapore history and culture. The newest kids in the block were the stacks of design books as well as flyers and catalogues picked up from exhibitions and galleries over the years.

Like sediment layers, these reflected my own evolution. But I treated the shelves more like a jigsaw to my life. Often, I appropriated, adapted and arranged the artifacts on the shelves to create self-portraits. As I cleaned the dust and looked at these things through time, I could review my life, revisit my memories and rewrite my story. Things that no longer mattered were thrown out, others gained prominence, and often, new connections were discovered.

The annual spring cleaning that comes with every Chinese New Year was always an opportunity  to give the room a major reconfiguration. For a while, I had a table integrated with the shelves as I sat facing the wall of books. When I wanted to expand my worldview, I shifted perspective to the windows instead. As the room’s edges ebbed and flowed, the only constant was an open space in the middle where everyday I laid out my tatami mattress—a gift from my parents who decided if I was to sleep on the floor then I should lie on something intended for it. Although they did not mean to do so, it was also a reminder that my room was still a part of their apartment.

As I approached thirty, it became more and more difficult to keep reshuffling my room. The shelves multiplied in numbers, and as more books and artifacts weighed them down, they sunk roots into the floors. The posters left their shadows on the lime green walls and clung on more desperately than before. Maybe, I was growing a little old too. Most definitely, I was settling.

That was when I decided that the only arrangement left was for me to leave the room and start afresh. To put down everything I had and lead a life of permanent impermanence again. That led me to the United States. For me, the bedroom was never a shelter for self-preservation. It was a room full of possibilities, where I wandered on a journey of self-discovery through the ritual of arrangements.

———–
Written for Akiko’s Busch Reading Design class at D-Crit.

Mourning & Memory: Recommendation Letters

I had discovered the letter while packing to leave for New York city. Sitting in the corner of a drawer was this sheet of folded paper, slightly yellowed with age.

Two words on it stood out: “Ngan Yow”.

That was the name of my grandmother, who had passed away 13 years ago. As both my parents work, she raised me up as a child. We used to share the room in the apartment, until she died when I was 16.

Before she took care of me full-time, my grandmother was an “amah”. It was what the British called domestic servants in Singapore when they still ruled the country. But I never knew much more than that, until I read the letter last August.

It was a recommendation written by her employer, a Mr. Michael J Cook. In 1980, some four years before I was born, my grandmother had decided to retire after serving the Cooks for 20 years. I later found out that she could finally afford her own apartment and my father, as well as both of my aunts, were already working.

The letter was addressed “To Whom It May Concern”, but it felt like a personal ode I had never written to my grandmother. Mr Cook praised her for being hardworking and reliable. I remember waking up bleary-eyed daily to see my grandmother up and about preparing breakfast and working on chores. Mr Cook said she cooked both Western and Chinese food. How can I forget the butter cakes and Cantonese soups that I never got to taste again? At the end of the letter, Mr Cook wrote, “It is with regret that we see Ngan Yow leave us after such a long time…”

I miss my grandmother too.

Ngan Yow

In many ways, recommendation letters are a kind of mourning. They are only written when someone you care about is leaving — to seek employment elsewhere or in pursuit of further studies. Writing it is bittersweet: as you pen what you loved about the person, you recall the good times together. It only makes the departure more poignant.

Reading Mr Cook’s letter reminded me how much I’ve lost with my grandmother’s passing. Her death was sudden, and I never got to say a proper goodbye.

I also thought of the recommendation letter a close friend wrote for my application to graduate school in New York. He had been the least excited about my departure, and I found out why when he insisted I read what he wrote. In it, he confessed it was selfish to have discouraged me from leaving, but only because of he would miss the great times we had together. In the end, he realized I wasn’t leaving, but going some place better for my career.

That is the other side of recommendation letters — they are messages of hope. They contain good memories we have of the departed, and the wish they end up someplace better too.

———–
Written for Akiko’s Busch Reading Design class at D-Crit.