Category: Cities

Of places and spaces

CRANES — not those of nature, but the industrial mammoths — are taking over this island.

On my daily travels on the MRT from Redhill to Boon Lay, as I watched new buildings grow, it struck me that these cranes were not just constructing but also de-constructing the space that used to be. What if I don’t recognise Singapore anymore one day?

I still remember my grandmother’s rants about how a space used to be something else. It is one of those things that you associate with ageing — you know you are old when you start talking like that. Yet, recently, I found myself talking just like that with my friends one day as we returned to Junction 8, a shopping mall at Bishan  that was our favourite after-school joint recently.

And, I’m only 23.

Junction 8 today has a new extension wing, more shops, a renovated food court and so much more. It felt surreal when I first stepped into it — familiar and alien all at the same time. I knew the place but not the space. My map of it no longer made sense.

Increasingly a lot of Singapore evokes similar sentiments. If there is anything symbolic of the agent of such a revolution, it has got to be those cranes that have overtaken Singapore’s skyline. Quiet, efficient at times and even graceful to watch, they seem virtually unstoppable.

Some say that their presence has griped the Singapore cityscape because its planners see it simply as a tabula rasa, a clean slate for it to construct its pragmatic ideals. Nothing will be spared from the crane—it is only a matter of time.

As Singapore greys, I think it becomes even more important that the burgeoning elderly community have spaces they can still remember. What use is it for the elderly to have money to retire or a job to survive if they exist in a space they cannot “navigate”?

The deputy chairman of the Preservation of Monuments Board in 1978, Professor Seow Eu Jin, once wrote that, “The purpose of preservation is to sustain life and to link the past with the present and with the future.” Thus, retaining these spaces shows a clear signal that we don’t just look towards the young, the new and the future but want to include the elderly too. Their memories of Singapore matter too.

Much of what has been preserved largely only reflects the desire to keep our memories of the colonial legacy and our religious identities. What seem missing are post-independence spaces for instance the old National Library or the Hilltop Apartments.

Yet, it is important for the people and not just the government who have to show a better understanding and appreciation of the space we’re living in. Must we always seek a spanking new development? Is the monetary value of a space worth more than the memories of a place?

Architect Timothy Seow, who designed many Singapore spaces in its formative years after independence felt that a lot of architecture projects designed then reflected a “Singapore built by Singaporeans” as many of them were undertaken by local architects.

However, many of them have been lost in the battle against the crane. Could these spaces not be essential to the Singapore story? Were these spaces taken away because they were tainted with post-independence stories of turbulence, poverty and upheavals that need eradicating?

That a space lacks popularity with Singaporeans does not make it less valuable to us. One instance of this is the Golden Mile Complex in Bras Brasah, a project of local architect William Lim. It was an experiment in mixed-used development, the idea of working, playing and living in one big space that had failed to take root. Shunned by locals, it has become a little Thailand, adding cultural flavour to a landscape increasingly dotted with corporate buildings and entertainment structures.

My worry lies with the rapid pace of change of the spaces I grew up in. Will I feel alienated to places I call home, and a city that is renewing faster than I age?

When I live past 85, I cannot be sure that I will remember this place or even what it used to be. But maybe, I’ll remember the cranes.

The Nanyang Chronicle, 29th Oct 2007

A Distracted City

“In a city, you are distracted by everything around… that you forgot about the people.” she said.

Indeed, a city is built to be seen, a visual showcase of wealth and power such that when you live in one you find yourselves more often than not looking up. Towering above you are skyscrapers, office towers, shopping malls, statues — the scale of things make you feel small.

If the vertical compression is not enough, you find yourself surrounded by crowds, cars, advertisements all around. You wish you had that little bit more elbow room to move, to think, but you are distracted by the sights around you. Should you move, or stay still? Either way, the barrage of the city weighs on all your senses and that is when you cave in.

But that is also when you learn its language and you find ways to ignore it. You build your own walls of resistance — listening to your iPod, taking short-cuts, ignoring what is around… and you forget the person next to you is doing the same as you.

The city squeezes more of us into the same space, but in doing so, puts just as much distance between you and I.

The 24-Hour Kopitiam: More Than Just Food

Below is a cultural report of the 24-hour Kopitiam in Plaza by the Park. It is posted here for an assignment as part of COM412: Journalism Reimagined.

In between the fringes of Singapore’s shopping belt and its civic district is this 24-hour food court, Kopitiam, that is part of a chain of similar stores island-wide that houses the “True Singapore Taste”. Indeed, traditionally, kopitiams are a general reference for the many independent-run shops locally that served food and coffee, but this store in Plaza by The Park, is an outlet of a corporation set up in 1988. On the evening of 14th of February 2009 I made the following observations at three different locations between 930pm to midnight.

kopitiam

While there is a wide array of food choices, 17 different stores, they are all run under one corporation. Regardless of the stores, all staff wore a uniform — a blue cap, white top with pink mandarin collar and a blue apron with the “Kopitiam” logo. This uniformity extended to the cleaners, hired from another company, who were decked out in yellow polos with a blue collar and some wore a blue cap. Such uniformity suggests a system was being implemented in this space.

A system of efficiency
As you can see in my map, efficiency was clearly in order in this Kopitiam. Distinct walkways for consumers sat next to lined up stores and were marked with different floor tiles from the sitting area. In order to maximise space usage, rectangle tables for two were placed right next to the glass panels that bordered the Kopitiam and tables for four were arranged orderly in areas A and B. Only in a small area of B did I find round wooden tables that were more common in kopitiams but were less efficient because less people could be packed into the same space.

All stores used a common cutlery pool — green trays and off-white bowls, spoons and chopsticks. Only the Minced Meat Noodle and Dessert stalls used different sets, the former had bigger black bowls and the latter blue bowls. Such uniformity justifies and aids a centralised cleaning service, and this is unlike traditional kopitiams where each stall usually cleaned their own dishes.

Efficiency pervaded right down to the cleaners who patrolled the place with a trolley that had separate compartments for food waste, dishes, cutlery and trays. At 11pm, the cleaners and many of the stalls had a change in staff, possibly marking the start of a new shift too.

Reclaiming the kopitiam
While Kopitiam tries to create an efficient dining experience like McDonalds — self-service, food is served quickly on trays that one can easily handle and cleaners constantly patrol the area to ensure that customer turnover was quick — the stall owners and customers defy this system in various ways.

Stalls like the Zi Char, Hokkien Mee and Handmade Noodle often got their customers to come back for their food instead of lining up as planned. The food they served probably needed some time to prepare, and when it was ready, customers were summoned back with the distinct sound of a bell.

While customers are free to sit anywhere, community enclaves were identified. Tables of Indians gathered around Jaggi’s North Indian Cuisine while men, mostly Africans, sat at section C so they could watch the soccer game projected on a screen over bottles of beer. Even the cleaners claimed the corner next to Bao Luo Wan Xiang to take short breaks.

Couples usually took up seats of four instead of two, putting their bags on the other two seats. When groups bigger than four came in, they rearranged the furniture to accommodate their numbers. Food here was usually served just for one, but a family of five foreigners created their own feast by buying from different stores and sharing them.

Some customers, like me, bought only a drink and sat down with their newspapers and books for hours. Two uncles sat through the whole time I was there, finishing over 6 bottles of Heineken beer — a common sight in kopitiams.

Rebel of consumption — ‘Dessert man’
After 11pm, the place was visibly less crowded and instead of customers, vagabonds started appearing. A few of them bought only a drink and were eventually slumped over the tables at the ‘sleeping corner’ near the North Indian cuisine. One example was ‘Dessert man’ whom I sat right next to for 1.5 hours. The middle-aged man armed with two big plastic bags bought a bowl of noodles and ordered a cup of tea. He had also asked for an extra empty cup.

After his meal, instead of ordering desert from the stall, he took out his own. The man had brought his own bottles of juices and biscuits and was very particular about the way he ate. He began with a bottle of Bickford’s Blackcurrant juice that he poured into the cup he had meticulously cleaned before with his own kitchen towels and started eating Munchy’s biscuits, making sure his hands never touched the biscuits as he ate them one after another from the packet. Next, he opened a bottle of Gerber Apple Juice, but not before cleaning the cup with water and tissue again. For the next half an hour, he finished nine packets of Cowhead biscuits, eating only the filling and spitting out the biscuit into a waste plastic bag he had created. By the time I left at midnight, he was done with his desert and was engrossed in reading his copy of Lianhe Wanbao, not looking like he was planning to go anywhere else.

Despite being a private space of food consumption, many of the customers at Kopitiam used it more than that, often as a gathering point for a community, a private space for people to read and even a home for the vagabonds.

——

If you’re interested, read a similar, but more imaginative study I did of Yangtze Cineplex here.